Shure E4c Sound Isolating Earphones Review

So that you know a little about me and this review, I will start by saying that I am a professional classical musician, and I have recently had a hearing test on which I did very well.I am also something of a headphone enthusiast, as I have some very expensive headphones, a high-end source and an expensive dedicated tube headphone amplifier.I am aware of a computer magazine review that recently rated the Etymotics higher in sound quality.

This is a comparison of the E4C and the Etymotic ER-4P, using the Gmini XS200 as a source, with mp3's encoded at either 192 or 256 kb/s.(By the way, the Gmini is a great little DAP!)Both of these earphones are quite good and will provide vastly better sound quality than the typical headphones and earbuds that fill the mass market.I like the included foam tips included by each manufacturer, so that is what I used to compare them.The Etymotic foam tips seal better and provide superior isolation from outside noise.I must note that the Shure's were bought new by me, and the Etymotics are a loaner from a friend.Please be aware that the Shure's require some "burn in", and will not sound their best new out of the package.Have patience at the beginning, and notice the improvement in performance over the first 20-40 hours.I do not know the break-in characteristics of the Etymotics.

I'll cut to the chase.The Shure's are sonically much more impressive than the the Etymotic's.Both are highly resolving and have no major faults.The Shure's however, sound as though they have even greater resolution of detail, and have a flatter frequency response.They represent the subtleties of instrumental timbre much more accurately, and include even more detail in their presentation. One can hear all the qualities of the recording environment, the position of instruments of the orchestra (soundstage), and seem to create a sound that is less bottled up within the ear (headstage).They do not have the least trace of sibilance.Somehow, in spite of all this resolution, they still sound smooth and convey all the beauty and warmth of tone one could want.They have slightly "rolled highs", as this is the practice of Shure in all their products, but this is a very small criticism since the treble region is nevertheless very clear, balanced and controlled.In comparison, the Etymotics have a sound that is a little "tipped up", and can become fatiguing.There is a comparative lack of depth to their sound, and there is much information in the midrange in particular that is lost.Bass is not as present, controlled, or quick.Beauty of tone is lacking.I do not have the same emotional response to the music with them.However, these are still not sibilant, and are still very fine.

The Shure's are also better built.I feel they are sturdier and less likely to be damaged from hard use.They are more microphonic than the Etymotics, though, which will be very annoying if you intend to use them while moving around.One should realize they are both very microphonic because of the nature of their isolating design, and therefore will transmit a lot of unwanted bumping and rustling to your ears if you move around with them.I recommend sitting still.

The Shure represents true high fidelity in a portable form.In many ways, they outperform my expensive home headphone rig.What is more, they sound this good without the need of a separate headphone amplifier.In fact, I recommend you skip the amp, as I felt that mine added too much energy to the treble.I am very impressed with them, and I strongly recommend them.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Shure E4c Sound Isolating Earphones

Product Description:
Digital edge technologies used for creating, transferring, and listening to digital music has made the iPod and various other Digital Media Players the most popular portable listening devices around the world. Shure recognized that at the start. Highly demanding and critical listeners have appreciated Shure earphones. Shure's E4c extends that enjoyment even further. The cutting-edge industrial design of the E4c is a breakthrough in sound isolating earphone technology. Ideal for the business traveler and on-the-go audiophile, the High-Definition Driver with Tuned Port Technology delivers brilliant highs and extended bass that enhance your listening experience with your portable DVD, MP3 and CD players as well as all other audio sources. The E4c's in ear design works like an earplug to block background noise naturally. This enables you to listen comfortably at lower volumes-even in loud environments. And unlike bulky headphones utilizing active noise cancellation technology, no artifacts are introduced into your listening experience. Sound isolating earphones are also much smaller and don't require batteries. 60 inch cable length 3.5 mm (1/8) gold-plated stereo plugAlthough the E4c comes with an assortment of sleeves to ensure a comfortable fit, some users may want something even more personalized. In this case, we recommend contacting a hearing professional, such as an audiologist, to make custom-fit ear molds for your E4c Color -WHITE

Want to buy Shure E4c Sound Isolating Earphones at other amazon sites? Click the corresponding icon below:

Shure E3g Gaming Edition Sound Isolating Earphones for Portable Gaming Devices Review

I own the Sony EX-71 earbuds and thought they were great compared to any other earbuds in the $40 range. In comparison, the E3g definitely has much greater clarity on the mids and highs. As low of a volume as I had using the EX-71, I could still turn the volume lower when using the E3g. Unfortunately, I found the bass to be richer using the EX-71. You can feel more of a bass reverb with the EX-71 versus the E3g. The E3g bass sounds tight and a flat. I don't like the foam pads that everybody uses. The middle-sized gray buds work great for me and look better. They are a tighter fit (literally pops out) than the middle-sized ones from the EX-71. I also picked the E3g over the E2g because I don't have to loop the cord around my ear.

As far as noise isolation, the E3g blocks out just a little more noise than the Sony EX-71 because of the slightly larger buds. Once you turn on the music (because of the mids and highs) it is much more effective at blocking out noise since your ears focus on the music. If you have $180 to burn, the E3g are the ones to buy but otherwise the Sony EX-71 is still a great buy. I still use both - E3g on the plane and EX-71 for workout (since I'm not sweating on my $180 headphones!!).

Click Here to see more reviews about: Shure E3g Gaming Edition Sound Isolating Earphones for Portable Gaming Devices

Product Description:
Raise your gaming to a whole new level (or get even greater sound from your Nano!).The Shure E3g helps you get your head in the game with the same award winning sound and design used in the E Series line.The E3g Sound Isolating (tm) Earphones with WideBand MicroDriver technology deliver extended-range audio with precision highs while blocking outside noise.Sleek and lightweight, the E3g is the perfect accessory for your portable gaming devices.The E3g includes a selection of interchangeable sleeves for a comfortable, personalized fit and a zippered carrying case.In cool black, like the hottest gaming devices.Shure makes audio equipment - microphones, earphones, mixers, etc. that are used by professional musicians the world over. Shure knows sound. If your sound is important to you, you want earphones engineered with the same kind of technology that your favorite divas and bands use to be sure they can hear themselves during a performance. That's Shure's "Sound Isolating" technology. Rather than introducing external elements to block out ambient sound (as noise cancelling earphones do), the Shure system creates a sealed environment that keeps noise out, without covering it up by injecting noise-cancelling artifacts that can interfere with your gaming or your music. You'll hear details you never heard before.

Want to buy Shure E3g Gaming Edition Sound Isolating Earphones for Portable Gaming Devices at other amazon sites? Click the corresponding icon below:

Klipsch Image X10 Noise-Isolating Earphone Review

I primarily use earphones with my iPod, particularly when traveling by air, which I do a lot.The Klipsch Images replaced an older set of Shure E3c in-ear phones that I had been using for about three years.The Klipsch phones are very light, and I found that their earpieces fit me better and were more comfortable to wear than the Shures.They sealed out noise very well.Most importantly, however, the sound of the Klipsch phones is superb, and noticeably better than the Shure phones, any iPod earbuds and even my full-size Grado SR125s.Bass response is astonishingly good.These are expensive, but if you want something small, light and of very high quality, these phones are a great choice.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Klipsch Image X10 Noise-Isolating Earphone

Product Description:
Not only is it the world's smallest and lightest full-range in-ear headphone design, the Klipsch Image fuses lifestyle, technology, and fashion to offer a personalized fit and deliver a precision-tuned acoustic experience. IMAGE earphones utilize translucent patent-pending Contour Ear Gels that are anatomically designed to accurately fit inside the human ear canal. These soft, oval silicon tips reduce ear fatigue as well as provide an amazing seal for excellent noise isolation and increased bass response. Because ear canal measurements vary, each IMAGE model comes with five different ear gel sizes: small, medium, and large single flange designs as well as small and large double flange designs. Exclusive extended-frequency KG926 balanced micro-armatures deliver a superior acoustic experience with all the delicate accuracy you have come to expect from Klipsch. IMAGE earphones feature aluminum bodies finished in beautiful anodized copper and sleek, streamlined black "tails." Aside from aesthetic appeal, these flexible "tails" reduce cable stress and serve as an acoustic dampener to minimize cable noise.

Want to buy Klipsch Image X10 Noise-Isolating Earphone at other amazon sites? Click the corresponding icon below:

Shure SE530 Sound Isolating Earphones Review

***** Initial review - September, 2007 *****

My first exposure to these headphones was through a friend at the office who purchased a set of Shure E500s about a year ago (the E500s are pretty much identical to the SE530s).When he told me (and the rest of us) how much he paid for them ($500+ for the E500PTHs) we collectively thought he was nuts and proceeded to ridicule the decision.

That was before we heard them.

I first heard the E500s when that same friend from the office was going to send his set back to Shure under warranty due to the wires cracking with part of the copper conductors exposed near the ear area.He figured he was getting a new set from Shure, so he may as well let us hear them.Well, I thought I was good with my Sennheiser CX300s.I was wrong.Really, really wrong.I put the SE500s through their paces with my Rio Karma loaded with tunes I personally ripped using CDEX and Lame at a high bitrate.I used material ripped from MFSL Ultradiscs, DCC and Sony Superbitmap discs as well as other good, dynamic recordings and remasters.I never knew IEMs could sound this good!The E500s were audio bliss!There were excellent highs, mids and lows, all crystal clear and accurate without distortion.One of the most amazing things about them was the soundstage.With good source material, I could hear different instruments as if they each had a direct line into my brain.You could easily hear the difference between good recordings and masterings and ones that are not so great.I was sold on the spot.To verify my new opinion, I had certain other guys at the office (who are also appreciative of quality audio) listen to them, and they were just as amazed.We all apologized.He let me borrow them overnight.That evening I listened to them on the train home and then literally went crazy listening to everything I could, including some 24-bit DVD audio on my home system.I listened to them all night.Broken wires or not, I did not want to return them the next day.

So in a nutshell, I loved them, but I could not justify spending the money on the SE530s ($430 at the time)...Here I thought my Sennheiser CX300s were good... errr.. but not SE530 good.Not even close.They were just not in the same league.

So I watched and waited here at Amazon and in about two weeks the price dropped $40 to $390.Alright, I had enough!That was my cue to buy!

That was a few weeks ago and I have no regrets.

The sound isolation is really good, easily blocking out most outside sound when using the supplied foams.Also, the foams are comfortable (for me) and I can leave them in for hours without fatigue.The result is that you tend to listen to the music at a slightly lower volume since the outside noise is so well blocked.But if you do want to crank it, the SE530s can handle it.I use them every day during my commutes on the train.They were definitely worth the money.

My only criticism (other than the price) is with the wires.The wires are too thick, heavy and stiff in my opinion.I wish they were more like the thin, light, extremely flexible silicon type wires like the ones on the Sennheiser CX300s.I don't know what Shure was thinking using these.As I said earlier in the review, my friend's E500's stiff wires were damaged after a year and I can see that happening with these too.Good thing the the SE530s have a two year warranty.I substituted the long extension that came with them with a highly flexible extension that came with a pair of Sonys... so much lighter and better.

Overall the wire situation is a small negative compared to a very big positive of the amazing sound reproduction.

One of the other reviewers here said it, don't listen to these headphones if you don't plan on buying them.If you love audio, once you listen through these SE530s, you cannot ignore them.

***** UPDATE: 10/9/2007 *****

I'm still amazed at just how good these sound.I've been using them every day during my daily rail commute to and from NYC from the suburbs.The isolation level they provide is amazing!Using the supplied foam ear pads, I can honestly say that it almost doesn't matter if the lady next to me starts yapping on her cell phone or if a group of tourists is having a loud conversation - I won't hear 'em.With these on, you are in your own world.You will notice some outside sound between songs or during very quiet passages, but for the most part, if you are using the foams and they are inserted correctly, you will be very well isolated.Highly recommended for commuters.The wires still suck though.

***** UPDATE: 7/30/2008 *****

Its been ten months since I purchased these SE530s and every day I use them, I'm glad I did.I use them on an almost daily basis during my rail commutes to and from the office and the sound quality has been nothing less than outstanding for both music and movies.The fact that you get all this clarity and resolution along with full bass AND that almost all outside noise is blocked makes them truly great.I cannot imagine better sounding headphones for any price.I have to laugh when I see people wearing bulky, full-sized headphones on the train - I would not want to to do that.

So, I've had no regrets regarding the investment... that is, until today.Today I noticed what I knew was inevitable... one of the wires has developed a crack in the insulation near the black molded rubber strain relief and has exposed the copper conductor beneath.Upon further inspection, the other wire is showing signs of imminent cracking in the same area.I have been so very careful as to only pull them out of my ears via the back of the drivers near the strain relief and frankly, I cannot imagine how I could have treated them any better and not had this happen.I know that I predicted that this *exact* thing would happen in my initial review (see above and in the comments section) but it sucks now that it actually did.I still cannot understand how Shure could be using these stiff, inflexible, poorly performing wires on an otherwise fine set of super-premium earbuds.Now I have to return them under warranty for replacement.I called Shure and they want me to ship the 530s back to them, insured, with my proof of purchase from an authorized dealer (which Amazon is) along with their RMA form and I should see a replacement in *TWO WEEKS,* maybe more.TWO WEEKS?For $400+ headphones I expect better service than this.They will not cross-ship me a new pair either as they are "not set up" to do that.Shipping them back will likely cost me at least $20 with the insurance.

The worst part of this is that I fully expect that I'm going to receive a brand new pair with the same issue waiting to happen again over the course of normal use.I know this because my friend from the office, who originally introduced me to the Shures, is now on his... get this... *FIFTH PAIR* of SE500/530s - as four sets have developed the same exact wire cracking issue within a period of only two years.I did some poking around on the internet and there are even other reviews here on Amazon that detail the *exact* same issue.WTF is Shure thinking?I can walk down the street to any electronics store and buy a $30 set of buds with wire that will not have this issue... how is it that a $400+ super-primo set does?You can't tell me that other people aren't returning them... FIX THE ISSUE WITH THE WIRES, SHURE!!!

I'll update this review again when I receive my replacement pair.

***** UPDATE: 4/21/2009 *****

I swapped out for a new pair of SE530s in December, 2008 - I'm not going into the mechanics of that, but I didn't go through Shure.The wire on this pair is definitely different than the wire on my first pair.It is a bit more flexible and a tad thinner.I know with the first pair, I predicted immediately that the wires would fail in the exact manner in which they eventually did fail.With this wire, it's more difficult to predict the longevity.It certainly feels a bit better, but I'm apprehensive to call the issue fixed.I've had this pair for about five months now and there are no signs of the cracking issue yet.The sound quality is still phenomenal and based on that alone, I think you will not be disappointed.As a side note, my coworker sent yet another pair back as the black rubber strain relief separated from the body on his left speaker.You cannot reattach it.I can see how that could happen, but so far I have no similar issue.

***** UPDATE: 9/28/2009 *****

In July I purchased a new 32gb Cowon S9 to replace my aging Rio Karma.The audio output quality of the S9 is truly excellent and the Shure SE530s together with the S9 sound amazing!But now the rubber strain relief on my left bud is separating, just like it did on my co-worker's pair back in April.This doesn't affect the sound at all, but it looks bad and since the wire strain relief is no longer functioning, the wire is SHURE to suffer.This is disappointing as I've only had this pair (my 2nd) for nine months.This kind of thing just shouldn't happen to super-premium, pricey IEMs.Since I've been very careful with them and research shows that these issues are common with the 530s, I know it's not due to mishandling or abuse.My two years of experience with them has shown that the 530s are super delicate and if you use them regularly, no matter how hard...Read more›

Click Here to see more reviews about: Shure SE530 Sound Isolating Earphones

Product Description:
Pure audio precision--the SE530 uses Triple TruAcoustic MicroSpeakers to create an expansive sound stage. A dedicated tweeter ensures that highs and mids are incredibly accurate and detailed, while dedicated dual woofers provide balanced, full-bodied bass. The Push-To-Hear Control (included with the SE530PTH) adjusts levels of external sound for maximum intelligibility.

Get 26% OFF

Want to buy Shure SE530 Sound Isolating Earphones at other amazon sites? Click the corresponding icon below: